Hotel companies mislead guests on pricing, finds Which?

white hand black sleeve opening brown door with brass handle into room with ned white cover in front of double window with greeny brown open curtains to the floor

Hotel chains misleading consumers on prices

Research from the consumer champion Which? has found that hotel firms are using potentially misleading pricing in adverts for their properties. How hotels reel you in with potentially misleading discount claims

Companies are baiting guests to book by showing “discounted” rooms with very few nights available at the advertised price.

Researchers collected thousands of example prices at 138 hotels during a six-month period.  These included examples of Travelodge advertising hotel rooms in London ‘from £55’ and outside of the capital ‘from £39’.

Its research found that “adverts were phrased in such a way as to create urgency and leverage consumers’ fears of missing out on a bargain”. In one example the advert read: “Book Your Room Now! Book Early So You Don’t Miss Out! Rooms from £55. Book Online Today. Book for Tonight.” However, 15 of the hotels Which? checked had fewer than 10% of rooms available at the advertised price. Yet there was nothing on the adverts to suggest limited availability.

For example, £55 rooms were available at the Travelodge London King’s Cross Royal Scot, representing only eight per cent of those Which? checked. The majority of rooms (64%) cost more than £100, and in one instance Which? found a room priced at an incredible £220.

Strangely, in some locations, there was a reasonable chance of getting the deal advertised. However, 66% of the rooms Which? checked were advertised at £39 or less.

The Advertising Standards Authority (ASA) guidance Committees of Advertising Practice (CAP) clearly states that in travel marketing, retailers must make it clear that stock is limited, and the availability of a product must be “spread evenly across the advertised travel period”. The Which? research into London hotels found that this was not happening.

Looking further afield, Which? found that during July and August Accor ran a “15% off member exclusive” offer for its French hotels on Facebook. One of the hotels included in the promotion, a Mercure property near the Eiffel Tower, looked like a bargain, with nightly rates advertised ‘from £129’, based on a two night stay. But, when Which? checked on the last day of the sale, it found no nights available at this price over the whole 64-day travel period. “The cheapest room Which? found was priced at £142, but the majority of nights (62%) cost well over £180, and peaked at £252.”

Which? found numerous examples of Accor hotels doing this. In total, 15 of 19 (79%) of their advertised properties had no rooms available at the promotional rate when Which? checked during the sale’s final days. According to the CAP code rules, the adverts should have been withdrawn if the promotional rate rooms were sold out. Were they ever available at all?

Hilton also continued to promote some hotels at the sale rate after they had sold out of rooms at that price. During September 2024, Hilton ran a “20% off” promotion for three months. With less than a month remaining Which? checked 13 of the participating hotels and found good availability at most (71%). Rooms were even still available at the advertised price at the DoubleTree by Hilton in London’s Chelsea.

However, when Which? checked availability at Hilton’s historic Grand Hôtel des Sablettes Plage – advertised as ‘from £133’ – it found no rooms at this price for the remaining 18 days of the offer period. In fact, the cheapest available night was £180. Although Hilton’s Ts and Cs stated the offer was ‘subject to availability’, this was not clear enough under the CAP code.

Which? comments:

In the past year, there have been multiple occasions where the ASA has taken action against firms for advertising breaches. Premier Inn, for example, was taken to task for a promotion advertising rooms in Edinburgh ‘from £35’. The ASA ruled that the offer was ‘likely to mislead’ due the low percentage of rooms available at the advertised rate. Earlier in November the ASA ruled against Eurostar for the second time this year, after an advert promoting fares “from £39’’ was found to have lacked significant booking availability.”

Despite the ASA taking action in these cases, Which? is calling for a review of Trading Standards to ensure adequate enforcement of consumer protection laws.

Naomi Leach, Deputy Editor of Which? Travel, said:

It is completely unacceptable that holiday companies feel they can push the boundaries, and it’s clear that stronger enforcement of consumer law is needed to ensure businesses know that misleading pricing will not be tolerated.”

I believe that this is also a breach of the Consumer Protection from Unfair Trading Regulations (CPRs) because it is deliberately misleading the consumer. I asked Which? for a comment about this. A spokesperson said:

“Our reasoning was that the CAP Code and ASA guidance are more detailed with regards to bait pricing in advertising (compared to the CPRs). We have however shared our findings with the Competition and Markets Authority (CMA), who may find it appropriate to consider compliance with the CPRs.”

 

View this post on Instagram

 

A post shared by Helen Dewdney (@thecomplainingcow)

Advice regarding booking and complaining about holidays and flights

Look out timber frame on a beach "researching, booking and complaining aabout holidays and flights. Tips, ideas and your rights"

 

How best to book and complain about holidays/flights/travel links to various articles regarding saving money and your rights when booking and taking holidays.

How to complain about a hotel all the things that can go wrong and how to complain about them

 

 

You might also like
Newsletter Sign Up

If this site or a response from me has helped you, please consider buying me some chocolate (don’t like coffee!) to help me continue to provide this free advice. Thank you!

Share:

You must be logged in to post a comment.